Too Faced Sweet Peach Glow & Papa Don’t Peach (Review & Swatches)

Too Faced Sweet Peach

Too Faced Sweet Peach – the (original) eyeshadow palette launch that broke the hopes and dreams of many people out there because the demand was just too damn high for the supply they had. I was (and still am) obsessed with that eyeshadow palette – it was one of my favourite launches of 2016!

Too Faced Sweet Peach Glow + Papa Don't Peach
Too Faced Sweet Peach Glow + Papa Don’t Peach

So when they decided to relaunch the eyeshadow palette as a permanent product, Too Faced also decided to expand the collection with a full range of peach lip oils (review of those coming soon), a blush/bronze/highlight palette (Sweet Peach Glow) and having a dig through their product archives to re-release the Papa Don’t Peach blush.

I was excited for the launch, but I almost wondered if it would be peach overkill. I mean, that’s a LOT of peach! But as I’ve been mentioning more and more lately – I’ve grown to almost REQUIRE scent in my products as it really elevates my mood while I’m doing my makeup. So I’ve come to the conclusion that I am 100% full steam ahead with these scented launches!

Too Faced Sweet Peach Glow palette
Too Faced Sweet Peach Glow palette

The item that had the most appealed to me when I saw the initial sneak peeks was the Sweet Peach Glow palette. It has the same metal tin packaging as the Sweet Peach eyeshadow palette – it snaps shut with a magnetic lid, has a decently sized mirror and is covered in a beautiful light to dark peach gradient.

Too Faced Sweet Peach Glow palette
Too Faced Sweet Peach Glow palette

Inside you’ve got a light beige-veering-peach highlighter, a bright peach blush and a pale, slightly warm, bronzer.

Too Faced Sweet Peach Glow palette
Too Faced Sweet Peach Glow palette

The palette does skew towards more fair-toned folk, although I think that impression is given off mostly by the bronzer which is quite pale. The peachy blush and the highlighter are definitely strong enough for medium-toned skin.

Too Faced Sweet Peach Glow palette - swatches
Too Faced Sweet Peach Glow palette – swatches

In swatches, you can see that the pigmentation is surprisingly strong (especially the bronzer – I was not expecting that!). I had read an awful lot of reviews that felt like the pigmentation of this palette was just not there, so I was really surprised when I tried it out myself because I’ve got a totally different viewpoint. The pigmentation is definitely there, but since these are more firmly packed gelee-type formula products, you need to use a stiffer brush to pick up the product.

Wearing Too Faced Sweet Peach Glow palette
Wearing Too Faced Sweet Peach Glow palette

On the face? I’m in love. I love the shade of the blush (but like… it’s coral, did you expect me to hate it?!), the bronzer is surprisingly not orange (hooray!) and the highlighter, although a bit more subtle than some of the “BAM! IN YOUR FACE!” ones that are currently on the market, is gorgeous!

Wearing Too Faced Sweet Peach Glow palette
Wearing Too Faced Sweet Peach Glow palette

The highlighter definitely provides a much softer glow and there is a very faint peachy tinge to it. LOVE!

Too Faced Papa Don't Peach blush
Too Faced Papa Don’t Peach blush

The other powder product Sweet Peach launch item was a re-release of their Papa Don’t Peach blush. (I never owned the singular blush packaging, but I did have it in a palette, so there’s a swatch comparison below.) In sticking with the Sweet Peach theme, it also has its own tin packaging with a mirror (I’m growing more and more in love with blushes that come with a mirror – it’s just so handy).

Too Faced Papa Don't Peach blush
Too Faced Papa Don’t Peach blush

The Papa Don’t Peach blush features a whopping 9 grams of product – which is easily three times more than your average blush!

Too Faced Papa Don't Peach blush
Too Faced Papa Don’t Peach blush

And, of course, it’s infused with peach fragrance AND has an embossed logo (just like the Glow palette) – I mean… if that’s not love at first sight, then I don’t know what is!

Too Faced Papa Don't Peach blush
Too Faced Papa Don’t Peach blush

I pulled out my Too Faced Everything Nice (2014 holiday) palette which has the only other copy of Too Faced‘s Papa Don’t Peach blush that I own. The shades are, of course, remarkably similar, but you will notice a slight difference in the swatch:

Too Faced Papa Don't Peach blush swatches - comparison with old version
Too Faced Papa Don’t Peach blush swatches – comparison with old version

Both versions of Papa Don’t Peach are incredibly luminescent – this is the kind of blush you don’t really need a highlighter with because it will definitely light up your face! The older version of Papa Don’t Peach is a touch deeper in tone, maybe a hint more pink. With the new version, I see more peach and a slight bit more of a sheen. All of that being said, I really doubt you’re going to notice a discernible difference on your cheeks between the two shades!

Wearing Too Faced Papa Don’t Peach blush

I avoided applying highlighter when I used this blush just so I could see more of the product at work. In comparison to the Sweet Peach Glow blush, the Papa Don’t Peach blush is definitely less bright and deeper in tone. I did notice a lot of luminescence added to my cheeks in real life with this blush, but I’m not seeing that translated on camera.

Wearing Too Faced Papa Don't Peach blush
Wearing Too Faced Papa Don’t Peach blush

Papa Don’t Peach is stunning – it’s an easy to apply shade that will match a wide variety of eye looks which makes this not only beautiful, but a workhorse product as well!

Final Thoughts

Both products have that luscious, juicy fake peach scent – so if you’re not a fan of scented products, I think you may struggle with these. However, for those of us who love our powder products to have a tasty scent… these are glorious!

Overall, I was extremely impressed with both the standalone Papa Don’t Peach blush, as well as the Sweet Peach Glow palette. I had seen a lot of not so favourable reviews for the Glow palette, so I was a little bit nervous to try it out. However, at first application, I loved them! I like the tone of all of the shades, and I like that the blushes can pack a pigmented punch. If, however, you’re of a far deeper skin tone, I think you’ll struggle with the Glow palette because it seems quite obvious that it caters to us paler folk. I would love to see Too Faced put out a deep version of this palette! For me though: these are absolutely stunning products and I am happy to welcome them in my Sweet Peach collection alongside the eyeshadow palette I bought early last year! <3

If you’re looking for the Too Faced Sweet Peach collection, you can snag it at Sephora (Canada/USA) or at Ulta (USA).

The products featured in this post were sent to me for review. This post may contain affiliate links.

8 thoughts on “Too Faced Sweet Peach Glow & Papa Don’t Peach (Review & Swatches)

  1. I freaking love that blush. I really never go for iridescent type face products but I surprised myself with this one. The face palette looks so pigmented on your skin, for me it’s like where’s Waldo. Although on the face the blush and highlight did have some impact

    1. It’s odd though – I swear the first time I put on the blush I was like “oh… NO. NOPE.” but the second, third and fourth times I was like “oh yessssssssss”. Bizarre!
      Hah! Where’s Waldo!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge