Buckle in guys, this is going to be a long one! Wet N Wild has released their anti-unicorn collection (their words) with their limited edition online-only launch of “Goth-O-Graphic”. This collection dips into the holographic trend (which is really just duochrome) while piggybacking on the anti-thesis of unicorns – skulls and a goth-esque vibe!

Let’s dig right in, because there’s a LOT of product to discuss!

The first item that piqued my interest (and terrified me a little to be honest) were the MegaLast Liquid Catsuit Liquid Eyeshadows. The reason I was little apprehensive about these was because my eyelids have never handled liquid eyeshadow very well. More often than not it’s a crease-y mess, but these colours were so beautiful it was hard not to get excited about them!

The Goth-O-Graphic colelction has four different shades and comes with your standard flattened doe-foot applicator.

Swatched out the shades are interesting in texture: the paler shades are more translucent whereas the darker onces are more opaque. Each colour has either flecks or flakes of shimmer.

The two palest shades – Pure Intension and Mystic Dreamer are on the more flakey side of the sparkle spectrum. You get a bit of a broken up glass type look on the eye.

It can appear quite chunky, but it’s a look I’ve gone back to with other products over the years and I do like the look of fragmented shimmer – I think it adds a bit of different dimension. I would also like to point out that the colours are a heck of a lot more pigmented on the eyes (two coats) than they were on my arm swatch. Hooray!

My favourite shade is definitely Goth Tears – it’s a stunning blue shifting purple that goes on smoothly (there’s no flakes in this one) and looks beautiful paired with cool toned shades. And best of all? I had no creasing with these shades!

The only one that didn’t work on me (and turned out to be an utter trainwreck) was Nyctophilia. I was so surprised at just how terrible this went on my eyes – as you can see it’s a clumpy mess and I didn’t even bother to finish my eye look because there was no salvaging it. It creased within seconds and applied patchily – this one is a total miss for me.

The liquid lipsticks released with the Goth-O-Graphic are a metallic version of their regular line up for MegaLast Liquid Catsuits (you can see my full review of that range here). Wet N Wild says that these have buildable coverage and can act as a holographic topper. Let’s keep in mind – none of this collection is actually holographic. Holographic shows you the colours of the entire rainbow spectrum – this collection is more on the duochrome side of things.

As per their regular line, these Metallic Liquid Catsuits have stubby packaging with a scooped doe-foot applicator. The scoop helps to collect product from the tube and evenly disperse it on your lips.

The first thing I noticed when I swatched these out is that they are INCREDIBLY dry. They come out of the tube rather clumpy – which is in stark contrast to their regular lineup which can feel thick, but also really fluid. These are… chunky. The colours are interesting and quite dimensional… but it’s like they’re already half dried out!

Wicked Pink is the softest you’re going to see out of this collection – not only in terms of shade, but it was also the least drying and clumpy to apply. I love the overall effect of this one!

Pastel Grunge is so freaking cool – pale blue with shots of silver sparkle thrown in. While the colour is really neat, it applied supper patchily and could not be layered without getting too thick and uncomfortable.

Hands down my favourite shade is Gunmetal Heart – I’ve never seen a shade like this before! It’s a pale grey with a lavender edge and it has copper micro-glitter in it. It’s so incredibly unique! (I wore this shade in my Pinky Rose Bright Lights palette review if you want to see it in action.) It is, however, quite drying and a little bit patchy.

Death To Unicorns is a charcoal shade with some brown and silver glitter thrown in. It’s a really neat shade to look at… but uncomfortable to wear and clumpy to apply.

I was extremely excited for these – these are the metallic version of their MegaLiner Liquid Eyeliner! While I’m not huge on the dip pot style of eyeliner, Wet N Wild does make some of my favourite shades (they’ve got an unreal blue that I love dearly) so I’ll excuse the applicator in favour of the beautiful colours they make!

But these are… chunky. Dare I even say… crusty? I’m cringing so hard while typing this out but these come out of the pot in BLOBS. The brush is so coated with product that I didn’t think I’d even be able to get a clean line.

In the end, after two coats the liner is opaque and it looks okay… but you can see the thick blobs clinging to the roots of my lashes. The easiest one to apply is the white as it’s the most fluid, but for the most part these are just too chunky for me.

And finally, the last few items in this collection are all highlighters. Wet N Wild released a whole whack of them with the Goth-O-Graphic collection, and I for one am always happy to see variety in highlighters!

The first item is the MegaGlo Highlighting Stick in the shade Hell-O Darkness (lol I love the name!). The stick is a cream highlighter with a blue-lavender shift. I found it to be more subtle on the face than I had expected. Somehow I’ve lost the photos I took of it on my face, so sadly I can’t share that, but definitely check out Melanie’s Versus: Milk Makeup Holographic Stick and Wet n Wild Mega Glo Highlighting Stick post – she has a great comparison and review there!

I’m more of a fan of powder highlighters, so I loved the idea of the MegaGlow Highlighting Powders with their skull imprints! One shade looks bright white in the pan but it comes across on the cheeks with a blue shift. The other is more of a pinker sheen and honestly has a lot of pigmentation – so much so that it really only works as a blush on me.

And the very last highlighter is the MegaGlo Loose Highlighting Powder in the shade Moon Tears. If you twist off the cap, you can see that the sifter is shaped like a skull!

And here they are all swatched out. I like that there’s variety in the highlighter shades that they’ve provided, but they’re all kind of unique – not just boring shades of champagne.

My absolute favourite was the loose highlighting powder in Moon Tears. This product reminds me so much of MAC Iridescent Powders (which are now discontinued). It’s got a similar texture to Silver Dusk, but it’s more on the slightly gold side of things (Silver Dusk was pink-white). This highlighter is absolutely BEAUTIFUL and I think it’s my favourite item out of this entire launch. One word of caution though – the sifter isn’t amazing and if you tip this upsidedown with the cap on, you’re going to end up with a ton of product in the barrel of the jar.

Of course, I also love a good shifty cheek highlighter, so I found the pressed highlighter White Raven to be absolutely beautiful. I love matching my highlighter with my eyeshadow, and it worked out so well with the liquid shadows from the same collection.

Final Thoughts

Wow, this collection is all over the place for me, and sadly there’s only a few items I would recommend to you. I adore Wet n Wild, and I felt like this launch had a lot of potential, but the products themselves just fell very short in terms of quality. Let’s run through each set of items:

• Liquid Catsuit Liquid Eyeshadows: These were surprisingly good given that I didn’t think they would work on me. The darkest shade – Nyctophilia – is a disaster though. Don’t buy that one, but get the rest of them – they’re lovely.
• Liquid Catsuit Metallic Lipstick: The shades are gorgeous, but they’re a clumpy, chunky mess. They’re unpleasant to apply and feel super dry on the lips. You might able to wear them with a matching lip pencil underneath… but I’d personally take a pass on all the shades. 🙁
• Metallic Liquid Eyeliner: Another no. Don’t buy these. The white was okay and the colours are pretty overall.. but I can’t handle how chunky these are to apply.
• Highlighters: These are so much fun! The Loose Highlighting Powder was definitely my favourite, then the pressed powders (White Raven in particular). The cream stick was okay, but it didn’t have enough oomph for me overall (maybe better suited to people who like more subtle colour).

Phew… that was a post and a half! Let me know what your thoughts were on the Wet N Wild Goth-O-Graphic collection! Don’t forget this is online only, so get it while you can!

The products featured in this post were sent to me for consideration. Post contains affiliate links.