It’s here! I’ve finally got my Challenge Week up for the Too Faced Peanut Butter & Jelly palette!

Although it’s only April right now, this is quickly becoming one of my absolute favourite palettes for the year. Enjoy!
I could barely wait to use this palette, so I made a YouTube tutorial on it right away! My goal was to use as many of the shades in the palette as I could… and I actually managed to use eight out of the nine!
Eyes
- Spread the Love through the top of my crease.
- Peanut Butter through the crease with Nuts About U layered on top.
- Peanut Brittle all over the lid.
- Jammin’ on the outer half of the lid.
- Extra Creamy on the brow bone.
- Bananas on the inner corner.
I lined my lower lash line with Jelly and used Jammin’ on the outer edge. I created the wing with Kat Von D‘s Tattoo Liner in Trooper and applied Better Than Sex mascara to my lashes. I also applied a pair of Bombshell lashes by House of Lashes.
Face
- Foundation: Make Up For Ever Ultra HD stick in Y225
- Bronzer: Too Faced Milk Chocolate
- Blush: Too Faced I Will Always Love You
- Highlighter: Too Faced Candlelight Warm Glow
- Lips: Too Faced Melted Chocolate Milkshake with Melted Coral in the center of the lip
Although this palette is very orange-focused, you can get a significant amount of looks out of it without using the oranges. So that was my goal with this look: use the OTHER colours!
Eyes
- Spread The Love through the crease.
- Bananas all over the lid and inner corner.
- Jelly on the outer corner and through the crease and used to line the lower lash line.
- Jammin’ on the outer corner.
- Extra Creamy on the brow bone.
On my lashes is Maybelline‘s Lash Sensational Full Fan Effect mascara.
Face
- Foundation: Make Up For Ever Ultra HD liquid in Y225
- Bronzer: Joe Fresh Sand
- Blush: Laura Geller blush n brighten in Pink Grapefruit with Too Faced Your Love Is King on top
- Highlighter: Too Faced Candlelight Warm Glow
- Lips: Clinique Licorice Pop
While a lot of these looks can run fairly similar because of the orangey-brown shades, I am 100% okay with that because I love a good warm eye! I stuck with using all matte shades for this look.
Eyes
- Spread the Love all over the lid.
- Peanut Butter through the crease.
- Peanut Butter Cup on the outer corner
- Extra Creamy on the brow bone
On my lashes is Maybelline‘s Lash Sensational Full Fan Effect mascara.
Face
- Foundation: Revlon Colorstay in 150 Buff and 200 Nude
- Bronzer: Joe Fresh Sand
- Blush: Milani Luminoso
- Lips: Clinique Melon Drop Pop
I was trying to figure out how to make looks appear different with this palette, so I opted for a halo eye with this one.
Eyes
- Spread the Love through the crease.
- Nuts About U on the outer half and outer half of the lid and through the crease.
- Bananas on the center of the lid.
- Extra Creamy on the brow bone.
On my lashes is Maybelline‘s Lash Sensational Full Fan Effect mascara.
Face
- Foundation: Revlon Colorstay in 150 Buff and 200 Nude
- Bronzer: Joe Fresh Sand
- Blush: Milani Love Potion
- Highlighter: Too Faced Candlelight Warm Glow
- Lips: Clinique Pop Lacquer in Love Pop
Neutral/warm/gold look for my last one!
Eyes
- Spread the Love through the top of the crease.
- Bananas on the inner half of the lid.
- Nuts About U through the crease.
- Jammin’ on the outer corner.
- Extra Creamy on the brow bone.
I used Kat Von D‘s Tattoo Liner in Trooper to create the wing and coated my lashes with Maybelline‘s Lash Sensational Full Fan Effect mascara.
Face
- Bronzer: Joe Fresh Sand
- Blush: Tarte Charisma
- Highlighter: Too Faced Candlelight Warm Glow
- Lips: Benefit Coralista gloss
The Too Faced Peanut Butter & Jelly palette can be purchased on Ulta.com for $36 USD. It’s limited edition, so get it while you can!